Buckeyes. Technically they’re nuts. But “Buckeye” is also an affectionate name Ohio residents call themselves, the football team at Ohio State University (the mascot is even an anthropomorphic Buckeye named Brutus), and of course, that most Ohioan of confections– a ball of peanut butter and powdered sugar rolled in chocolate.
That little candy has the ability to make former Ohioans very nostalgic for their homeland. Just this week I visited the Meadowlands Fair in New Jersey and passed a stand selling various deep fried goodies and was surprised to see that the Buckeye had made its way over.
Today I made the first batch of Buckeyes I’ve made in years. They were typically a Christmas treat in my house (along with No Bake Cookies and Potato Candy). Today, however, the candies were requested by my friend Steve Slaybaugh, another Ohio ex-pat, to give out to attendees at one of his monthly mixers tonight.
Steve decided to create a space for those of us who made the 500-mile trek from our homeland. OhioNYC is a website that gathers news relevant to our kind. He also hosts the above-mentioned mixers at Park Slope bar The Owl Farm. These mixers are typically DJ’d by an Ohioan and prizes are given out, including OhioNYC t-shirts and coupons for Jeni’s and Graeter’s ice cream (which all good Ohioans know are the numbers one and two ice cream in the world).
Tonight, my husband Robert Duffy will be DJing and I will be providing the Buckeyes. If you’re in the area and would like to sample a Buckeye (and also maybe get a discount on beers!), the event starts at 8:30.
If you’re not in Brooklyn and would prefer to make these rich little bites at home, please see the recipe posted below. I decided to alter a key ingredient and dipped my peanut butter balls in melted dark chocolate candy melts rather than melted milk chocolate. I prefer dark chocolate anyway and candy melts keep the Buckeyes from becoming a big melty mess.
Makes about 4 dozen
1-1/2 cups Peanut Butter
1 cup unsalted butter, softened
1/2 teaspoon vanilla
6 cups powdered sugar
24 ounces dark chocolate candy melts
Cream the Peanut Butter, butter and vanilla in the bowl of a stand mixer until combined and mostly lump-free. Slowly add the powdered sugar; mixture will look dry and crumbly. Using your hands, roll the mixture into one-inch balls and place on a parchment paper-lined cookie sheet. Place a toothpick in each ball. Once all the balls are formed, put the cookie sheet in the freezer for 30 minutes.
Once the balls are frozen, melt half the candy melts in a shallow microwave safe bowl for about one minute. Remove the bowl and stir. If the candy melts are not smooth, continue to microwave in 10-second increments, stirring after each increment, until the mixture is smooth.
Remove the balls from the freezer and using the toothpick as a handle, dip each ball in the chocolate mixture, leaving a small circle of peanut butter uncovered to mimic the look of a real Buckeye nut. Let the excess chocolate drip off and put the ball back on the parchment paper-lined cookie sheet. Repeat until all balls are dipped, adding and melting more candy melts as needed.
Put the cookie sheet back in the freezer for a few minutes to let the chocolate completely harden. You can then remove the cookie sheet and transfer your Buckeyes in a single layer to an air-tight container. If the chocolate spread when you put the balls on the cookie sheet, you can pretty easily snap off any excess around the bottoms (or use a knife if you want to be really precise).
Keep the Buckeyes refrigerated until you’re ready to serve.