Ice Cream Week continues! Today I’m spotlighting the Watermelon Lemonade Sorbet I made using the recipe from Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams at Home.

I love lemon. It’s one of my favorite flavors. There’s a lemon frozen yogurt recipe in this book that’s calling my name, as soon as I get the time I need to prep that thing (you have to let yogurt strain for at least 8 hours in advance!). I’m also a fan of watermelon, as long as I eat it with a fork so I can pick all the seeds out. I hate taking a big bite of watermelon and ending up with a mouthful of seeds.
Therein lies the problem with this recipe. You are instructed to cut watermelon into chunks, remove the seeds and then puree it. Removing seeds from watermelon isn’t the easiest task. The black ones come out all right, but those little yellowy ones do not want to let go. Then you’re instructed to remove one cup of the puree and reserve the rest for another use. I’m not sure what that other use is, so I just cut a little at a time and pureed it, until I ended up with a cup. And that cup was mostly liquid.
I don’t know about you, but when I think of ‘puree’, I picture applesauce. Or baby food. A thick, pudding-like substance. I put my watermelon chunks in my food processor and two pulses later, I had watermelon juice. There was very little by way of watermelon ‘puree’.
I went ahead with the recipe and churned the liquidiness in my ice cream maker. 20 minutes later, I had a good-looking consistency, but when I stopped the machine and started to scoop it out, I noticed there was still a lot of liquid in the bottom of the machine. I churned for about five more minutes, but I started to get nervous that I was going to make my sorbet crumbly, so I stopped the machine, poured it all into a container, gave it a stir to incorporate the liquid, threw it in the freezer and said a quick prayer to the baking gods.
Well, it froze solid. There was no scooping of this sorbet. It was more like a granita. I had to chip at it to get a bowl full.

But man, oh man, it tasted fantastic. Slightly tart, a little bit sweet, big lemon flavor mixed in with that watermelon. We served it to friends and one of them (a vegan chef!) told me it was the best sorbet she’d ever had.
I posted my problem on the forum at Jeni’s website to see if I could get any pointers. I was told that the sorbet should not be liquidy while churning and that the puree consistency will depend on the sweetness of the watermelon. Great. I can’t very well tell how sweet the watermelon is without cutting into it and eating it. A few other people posted, commenting that they had the same problem, so maybe Jeni will look into this one and tell us all what we’re doing wrong.
Stay tuned! Coming up next will be the Darkest Chocolate Ice Cream in the World!